Monday, August 12, 2013

Tradition

For quite some time now I've been of the mind that traditions can be really silly, but sometimes silly is okay as long as we realize it. And not every tradition is silly. For example, I wouldn't say toasting to an occasion, sending birthday cards, or having graduation ceremonies are silly but I'd also argue that seeing the upside of these traditions is glaringly obvious while the downsides are minimal. And then there are traditions that I'd argue are pretty vitally important, like that one where parents take care of their children. The "silly" traditions I'm really thinking of are the one's that either make certain aspects of life uncomfortable for people or in someway make them feel an obligation to do things in a certain way when the reasons for the initiation of those traditions are either outdated or where possibly just simply ridiculous to begin with. Think, for example, the horror with which some will react to woman wearing white after Labor Day. In many places there could be a very practical reason why people would want to wear white(or other light colored clothing) during the warm summer months, but there is no practical reason why some arbitrarily designated day on a calendar should determine when it is no longer acceptable to do so. This is very trivial example of the type of silly traditions that I'm talking about, but an example none the less. Some people, or group of people, somewhere along the way decide that things should be done a certain way for reason that may have been ill defined or may no longer be relevant but we decide to keep on with them.

And this brings me to the specific issue that sparked this entry: engagements. Love is beautiful and so on and so forth, but the traditions(and I'm speaking specifically of the U.S. in this case) we have built and continue to take part in around this idea are a bit silly. This comes up because time has neared that I will propose to my longtime girlfriend and we recently went to take a look at engagement rings since I know nothing about jewelry. I've thought about this strange tradition that persists into our society before, but it occurred to me as I looked down at the pricetags that start in the thousands for tiny ancient pieces of carbon held on small rings of soft metal that ultimately have no use other than looking pretty how little logical sense it makes to have to follow this tradition other than for traditions sake. I've long argued that "because its tradition" is really no argument at all for doing things a certain way, we'd have a lot of very nasty "traditions" persisting today if that were the case and we'd have no case to say they're wrong. From what I can glean, the engagement ring tradition as it currently stands in the U.S. started as a result of a few different factors but two major ones were a marketing campaign by De Beers in an effort sell more diamonds combined with social norms that A) made it difficult for a woman to support herself without a man and B) had it that a woman that was no longer a virgin would have a difficult time finding a husband. The marketing campaign likely followed in a similar fashion as they do now- if you're cool, dignified, successful, a worthwhile person and real man then you'll spend X amount on your lady's diamond. The second aspect is that should you proposed to a woman and then take her virginity it will be hard for her to make it on her own as well as find another man that will want an unchaste woman so the ring's value will help her get by for awhile should the engagement be broken off. Fast forward to the year 2013- in most of the country these norms no longer hold with regard to both women's ability to support themselves as well as the expectation that she must be a virgin to find a husband. Furthermore, recent studies suggest that women are now making more than men within my specific age group(and my specific situation falls in line with this as well.) All this is to ask- why is this still the tradition for people my age? A woman can know she wants to marry her but feels she has to sit around and wait for him to be ready to ask? She has to wait until after he's stressed out about finding the right ring and possibly going into debt to pay for it, but why does this make any practical sense in the year 2013? Not to say all men stress out or go into debt, some may enjoy it even. But if you don't? Tough luck. Just how 'weird' would it be if a man were to get down on one knee with a flower, or the woman got down on one knee with a watch, or together the couple just said "lets get married."? Would that make the relationship or future marriage less valuable or meaningful? Is "tradition" really good enough reason to say things have to be this way?

Well....apparently it is. :-) Because I'll be following along even if I think its silly, because I want to be with her and I want her to have things her way(within reason.) Aaaand this brings us to what may be a future topic: things we do that we don't agree with simply to make the people we love happy.